Any good recommendations for in-car & long range communications these days?
I'm probably about to grab a Rugged Radio GMRS radio. We misplaced the antenna on one of the handhelds last trip. So that is motivation to get something permeant I won't be able to forget at home. I'll keep the hand helds around as spares for fiends. I'm probably goning to go with a RR over something else as they are weatherproof & already have the appropriate plugs for a hard wired intercom. I was going to go with a GMR25 as 25 watts should be fine, but then started eyeing up the G1 as it has the Bluetooth interface & was wondering if that might be worth it. I have my HAM radio extra license, but that's not really useful as nobody I ride with has anything but GMRS. I could mod a HAM radio, but I'd have to do a MARS/CAP mod & hack in a port for an intercom. I'm very capable of that, but I may as well stay within the FCC regs & save the time, unless there is a super compelling reason.
We have a 4 seater RZR Pro XP we use. A spare old Artic Cat Wildcat 2 seater for friends if we ever figure out a spare trailer & vehicle to tow it. Friends will probably be stuck with a hand held & spare hearing protection though.
Key requirements:
Hearing protection (I have enough tinnitus I need to protect what I have from a loud SxS)
Radio for talking to other vehicles up to a mile or two away. Needs to be weather resistant. We ride in the Rockies so lots of trees & twisting roads around the side of a mountain limiting line of sight & lower power radios. Bluetooth & line of sight mesh systems won't cut it. Basically GMRS as that's the most common around here.
Intercom for talking with up to 4 people in the vehicle. May skimp on headsets for back seaters for now.
Options I'm currently aware of:
Anything I've missed for options or pros & cons?
I'm probably about to grab a Rugged Radio GMRS radio. We misplaced the antenna on one of the handhelds last trip. So that is motivation to get something permeant I won't be able to forget at home. I'll keep the hand helds around as spares for fiends. I'm probably goning to go with a RR over something else as they are weatherproof & already have the appropriate plugs for a hard wired intercom. I was going to go with a GMR25 as 25 watts should be fine, but then started eyeing up the G1 as it has the Bluetooth interface & was wondering if that might be worth it. I have my HAM radio extra license, but that's not really useful as nobody I ride with has anything but GMRS. I could mod a HAM radio, but I'd have to do a MARS/CAP mod & hack in a port for an intercom. I'm very capable of that, but I may as well stay within the FCC regs & save the time, unless there is a super compelling reason.
We have a 4 seater RZR Pro XP we use. A spare old Artic Cat Wildcat 2 seater for friends if we ever figure out a spare trailer & vehicle to tow it. Friends will probably be stuck with a hand held & spare hearing protection though.
Key requirements:
Hearing protection (I have enough tinnitus I need to protect what I have from a loud SxS)
Radio for talking to other vehicles up to a mile or two away. Needs to be weather resistant. We ride in the Rockies so lots of trees & twisting roads around the side of a mountain limiting line of sight & lower power radios. Bluetooth & line of sight mesh systems won't cut it. Basically GMRS as that's the most common around here.
Intercom for talking with up to 4 people in the vehicle. May skimp on headsets for back seaters for now.
Options I'm currently aware of:
- Rugged Radio GMRS + Intercom - Fits most of the requirements, but headsets aren't wireless & it's around $1,500 for a full setup. Wireless headsets would be nice instead of the wired ones, but not a deal breaker.
- Peltor ComTac 6 headsets - I already have a pair for me & my wife. They are good noise canceling headsets, but the "Natural Interaction Behavior" peer to peer short range wireless doesn't work well for us. The voice activation is inconsistent enough you can't rely on it, so you have to push the button on the headset, which is annoying & inconvenient. They use a low impedance mic, so aren't compatible with most normal high impecence gear. Coincidentally I think Rugged Radios also uses "non-standard" low impedance, so they likely will work there. Even if they worked great, I'd still need to get a GMRS radio.
- Cardo Packtalk - Wireless, but not enough range for talking to another vehicle out of line of sight. Unclear if I could use these with a Bluetooth GMRS radio. At over $400 a pop, 2 cost about as much as as a RR intercom system & 2 headsets.
- Bluetooth headsets (PackTalk?) & Rugged Radio G1 (with Bluetooth) GMRS radio. Would cut out an intercom, but I'm not sure how much that would save in terms of time or money. May end up like our ComTac's where it doesn't work as reliably as I'd like.
- https://www.rzrforums.net/threads/d...t/threads/diy-communication-systems-and-inexpensive-radio-options.566321/unread doesn't seem like an option as it doesn't support an external radio & he's moving away from it to Packtalks or something.
Anything I've missed for options or pros & cons?